How do employers pay by production, please excuse my ignorance on this. If you're an employee, are they paying by line like an IC?
Yes, exactly.
I'm just trying to figure out if the decrease in pay as an employee with benefits will be a wash for making more money as an IC but paying for my own insurance.
Only you will be able to do the math on this one, once you have the figures to plug in to the equation. Let's say you got an offer of 9 cpl (only picked for ease of math, you probably will not get offered that much). This would represent a reduction of at least 25% - assuming that you could produce the same number of lines on average that you had been (you probably would not, at least for a while). Now you can figure if the 25% (or more) less is worth it in your situation.